Follow Us


Contact Us

76 -78 Castle St, Belfast, BT1 1HD

ciaran@finucanetoner.com

028 9027 8888

Send us an email

Case Studies:

Police unlawfully spied on journalists
December 18, 2024

PSNI and Met Police acted illegally by spying on two Belfast journalists

In October 2017, the PSNI announced that it had requested Durham Constabulary to investigate No Stone Unturned, a documentary that detailed how the RUC had colluded with and protected UVF killers involved in the murder of six men in Loughinisland on the 18th June 1994.


Durham Constabulary was tasked with leading an "independent" investigation, as the PSNI could not be seen investigating itself. On the 31st August 2018, our client, Barry McCaffrey and colleague Trevor Birney were arrested and questioned regarding the alleged theft of sensitive intelligence documents and breaches of the Official Secrets Act. John Finucane acted for Mr Barry McCaffrey, journalist and co-creator of the film, throughout.


In June 2019, senior judges ruled that the arrests had been unlawful. Mr McCaffrey and Mr Birney received a public apology from then PSNI Chief Constable Simon Byrne, as well as substantial financial damages of £875,000.


When faced with the likelihood of severe penalties from the IPT, Durham Constabulary disclosed that the PSNI had, in fact, been responsible for all unlawful activity.


What is the Investigatory Powers Tribunal?


The Investigatory Powers Tribunal (IPT) is an independent judicial body that investigates complaints about the conduct of public authorities in the UK.


Our client, Mr McCaffrey writes in the thedetail that, "since its inception in 2001, the IPT has looked at 4,073 complaints against the various intelligence agencies. It has only found in favour of complainants in 1% (47) of those cases." This highlights the significance of yesterday's judgement which declared that the PSNI and Metropolitan Police acted illegally by spying on the journalists. The IPT ruled that the PSNI were to pay each journalist a further £4,000.


Speaking from London, John Finucane said:


“Today’s ruling by the Investigatory Powers Tribunal is resoundingly and rightly in favour of the powerful work of journalists, including the exceptional Trevor Birney and Barry McCaffrey.


As these investigative journalists carried out their job, including assisting victims and families, police forces and state bodies from across these islands sought to criminalise them for doing so.


This is a momentous day vindicating the work and relentless determination of these two remarkable journalists.”




SHARE

By KIERAN MCNICHOLL March 13, 2025
Client left with residual scarring to hand
By KIERAN MCNICHOLL March 6, 2025
£60,000+ damages for clients involved in road traffic collision
January 29, 2025
Delivery Driver Injured at Work
By KIERAN MCNICHOLL January 23, 2025
Victims' Payments Board Payment of £120,000+
By KIERAN MCNICHOLL November 14, 2024
Family awarded £75,000 following Death in Workplace
By KIERAN MCNICHOLL November 5, 2024
Boy knocked down en-route to school to receive £30,000 in compensation
By KIERAN MCNICHOLL October 30, 2024
Pre-proceedings settlement of £17,500 for client following collision in Belfast
By KIERAN MCNICHOLL September 19, 2024
Human Rights Breach
September 4, 2024
Compensation for client involved in road traffic accident
August 14, 2024
£75,000 compensation for cyclist
More Posts
Share by: